Harbor Freight Torque Wrench
12-29-2008, 12:18 PM
#22
Senior Member
Join Date: 07-05-2008
Location: Akron Ohio
Posts: 5,464
My dad was an ASE certified Master Technician and now repairs city buses. I'm pretty sure he's done a lot heavy duty work and the Harbor Freight tools (sockets, screw drivers) have been better than his collection of Snap-on and Mac Tools.
Then again, the Chinese probably just make them out of heavier steel so they hold up better.
Then again, the Chinese probably just make them out of heavier steel so they hold up better.
ASE mechanics use cheap tools just as the rest of us and we all have had many cheap tools and most are not as good or break.
Not everything is bad at Harbor as I have stated in a past post but there is a lot of "you get what you pay for". If you don't pay much for it then don't complain when it breaks.
These kind of tools are good for things you don't use everyday. But if your working flat rate in a dealer you can't afford to suffer a broken tool as it could cost you more money vs you saved on the genric cheap tool.
I buy tools there but I just use care in what I buy. Some of their things are goo but many are you get what you pay for.
Heavier Chinese Steel?
12-29-2008, 02:56 PM
#23
Platinum Member
Join Date: 05-09-2006
Location: "Upland" Mesa, Arizona
Posts: 6,805
Like I said if you think so then I am happy for you.
ASE mechanics use cheap tools just as the rest of us and we all have had many cheap tools and most are not as good or break.
Not everything is bad at Harbor as I have stated in a past post but there is a lot of "you get what you pay for". If you don't pay much for it then don't complain when it breaks.
These kind of tools are good for things you don't use everyday. But if your working flat rate in a dealer you can't afford to suffer a broken tool as it could cost you more money vs you saved on the genric cheap tool.
I buy tools there but I just use care in what I buy. Some of their things are goo but many are you get what you pay for.
Heavier Chinese Steel?
ASE mechanics use cheap tools just as the rest of us and we all have had many cheap tools and most are not as good or break.
Not everything is bad at Harbor as I have stated in a past post but there is a lot of "you get what you pay for". If you don't pay much for it then don't complain when it breaks.
These kind of tools are good for things you don't use everyday. But if your working flat rate in a dealer you can't afford to suffer a broken tool as it could cost you more money vs you saved on the genric cheap tool.
I buy tools there but I just use care in what I buy. Some of their things are goo but many are you get what you pay for.
Heavier Chinese Steel?
hey Hyper...
I agree, 100%.
However, after purchasing THREE Harbor Freight 50 foot air hoses (made in India) and all had a defect within 30-45 days, I changed over to Goodyear (says Made in USA). The Goodyear is still in service with no problems.
The Harbor Freight hoses had delamination with air "blisters"......split about 25 feet into the hose.......and split at the air coupling. I had to essentially argue with the store manager for replacement, especially after the inital warranty period of 30 days (on the second one). As stated, finally purchased a Goodyear from them and paid the difference. Manager said, the "home office" stated it was a bad batch.
And by the way...the Chinese do make HEAVIER steel....just not a quality composition (i.e. many of our rotors). Also would you believe, it took them almost 4 years to get the metal composition and specs to the Buick wheels correct. It was kind of expensive in lots of 200 engineering samples submitted each time.....not to mention sending them on wood pallets that were contaminated by some type of bug and had to be quarantined.
Needless to say, I'm not a strong supporter of Chinese product.
Anyway, a cheap tool is good when the owner accepts the fact that it is a disposable. Kind of a one time job.
12-29-2008, 04:41 PM
#24
Senior Member
Join Date: 01-14-2006
Location: Waterford, MI
Posts: 230
Why?
I wounder how much a Snap-On, MAC or Craftsman torque wrench really costs. If you were to remove the number of profit centers in these organizations (that do not exist with in Harbor Freight), how much would the torque wrench cost?
Price (alone) should not be used as an indicator of quality.
I wounder how much a Snap-On, MAC or Craftsman torque wrench really costs. If you were to remove the number of profit centers in these organizations (that do not exist with in Harbor Freight), how much would the torque wrench cost?
Price (alone) should not be used as an indicator of quality.
12-29-2008, 05:36 PM
#26
Senior Member
Join Date: 07-05-2008
Location: Akron Ohio
Posts: 5,464
hey Hyper...
I agree, 100%.
However, after purchasing THREE Harbor Freight 50 foot air hoses (made in India) and all had a defect within 30-45 days, I changed over to Goodyear (says Made in USA). The Goodyear is still in service with no problems.
The Harbor Freight hoses had delamination with air "blisters"......split about 25 feet into the hose.......and split at the air coupling. I had to essentially argue with the store manager for replacement, especially after the inital warranty period of 30 days (on the second one). As stated, finally purchased a Goodyear from them and paid the difference. Manager said, the "home office" stated it was a bad batch.
And by the way...the Chinese do make HEAVIER steel....just not a quality composition (i.e. many of our rotors). Also would you believe, it took them almost 4 years to get the metal composition and specs to the Buick wheels correct. It was kind of expensive in lots of 200 engineering samples submitted each time.....not to mention sending them on wood pallets that were contaminated by some type of bug and had to be quarantined.
Needless to say, I'm not a strong supporter of Chinese product.
Anyway, a cheap tool is good when the owner accepts the fact that it is a disposable. Kind of a one time job.
I agree, 100%.
However, after purchasing THREE Harbor Freight 50 foot air hoses (made in India) and all had a defect within 30-45 days, I changed over to Goodyear (says Made in USA). The Goodyear is still in service with no problems.
The Harbor Freight hoses had delamination with air "blisters"......split about 25 feet into the hose.......and split at the air coupling. I had to essentially argue with the store manager for replacement, especially after the inital warranty period of 30 days (on the second one). As stated, finally purchased a Goodyear from them and paid the difference. Manager said, the "home office" stated it was a bad batch.
And by the way...the Chinese do make HEAVIER steel....just not a quality composition (i.e. many of our rotors). Also would you believe, it took them almost 4 years to get the metal composition and specs to the Buick wheels correct. It was kind of expensive in lots of 200 engineering samples submitted each time.....not to mention sending them on wood pallets that were contaminated by some type of bug and had to be quarantined.
Needless to say, I'm not a strong supporter of Chinese product.
Anyway, a cheap tool is good when the owner accepts the fact that it is a disposable. Kind of a one time job.
I know they make different compsition steel but I don't think his comment was that deep. I was just thinking my 6 pound sledge from their is really 8.5 pounds.
Your last comment is spot on. IF you buy cheap you accept what ever service life you get with out complaint. Some you get lucky and get a good item some you jsut don't but if you did not pay much you can't complain.
12-29-2008, 06:05 PM
#27
Senior Member
Join Date: 07-05-2008
Location: Akron Ohio
Posts: 5,464
Why?
I wounder how much a Snap-On, MAC or Craftsman torque wrench really costs. If you were to remove the number of profit centers in these organizations (that do not exist with in Harbor Freight), how much would the torque wrench cost?
Price (alone) should not be used as an indicator of quality.
I wounder how much a Snap-On, MAC or Craftsman torque wrench really costs. If you were to remove the number of profit centers in these organizations (that do not exist with in Harbor Freight), how much would the torque wrench cost?
Price (alone) should not be used as an indicator of quality.
As for a cheap torque wrench you need to understand if it fails head gaskets fail, wheels come off and exhaust leak. All that money you save will be lost and then some if a crittical tool fails.
Now also keep in mind you get what you pay for 95% of the time but can you afford an important part to fail with a cheap wrench. The bottom line is this tool has tested poorly vs the name brand other wrenches.
Three things not to cheap out on Crash helmets, Parachutes and Torque wrenches.
If your going cheap do it with a combination wrench or creeper as there ar emany things you can cheap out on but this is not one I would recomend. Besides a good wrench will last a life time.
The best things in life are not free and you seldom get high quality with low price. You don't always have to pay the highest price but $15 is a sign your taking a great risk and can you afford the failure?
Harbors only going to give you a new wrench if it fails but they will not replace the failed engine or fender you lose wheel just took out.
I have seen too many people cheap out and spend twice as much to fix what they save money on.
12-29-2008, 06:16 PM
#28
Member
Join Date: 06-16-2008
Location: ohio
Posts: 45
I wonder if putting on lug nuts with a torque wrench that is off by 6-11 ft. lbs. is any worse than the nuclear powered air impact wrenches that they use at the dealer or tire stores to twist them on so tight that you could never get them loose on the road if you have a flat?
True story that also involves the puny useless tire tool that they give you in an HHR to change a tire with that makes for a nice looking metal pretzel to throw into the woods in anger after trying to get a lug nut loose. Now I carry a large 4-way wrench under the floor in rear of the car.
True story that also involves the puny useless tire tool that they give you in an HHR to change a tire with that makes for a nice looking metal pretzel to throw into the woods in anger after trying to get a lug nut loose. Now I carry a large 4-way wrench under the floor in rear of the car.
12-29-2008, 06:40 PM
#30
Senior Member
Join Date: 07-05-2008
Location: Akron Ohio
Posts: 5,464
I wonder if putting on lug nuts with a torque wrench that is off by 6-11 ft. lbs. is any worse than the nuclear powered air impact wrenches that they use at the dealer or tire stores to twist them on so tight that you could never get them loose on the road if you have a flat?
True story that also involves the puny useless tire tool that they give you in an HHR to change a tire with that makes for a nice looking metal pretzel to throw into the woods in anger after trying to get a lug nut loose. Now I carry a large 4-way wrench under the floor in rear of the car.
True story that also involves the puny useless tire tool that they give you in an HHR to change a tire with that makes for a nice looking metal pretzel to throw into the woods in anger after trying to get a lug nut loose. Now I carry a large 4-way wrench under the floor in rear of the car.
But I was younger then.